| NECC 2018 | ||
| Nick Langat | M | 3rd Team |
| Carlos Ponce | M | Del Malloy Sportsmanship Team |
| NECC 2017 | ||
| Jared Lacoste | F | 2nd Team |
| Lee Dennis | M | All-sportsmanship |
| NECC 2016 | ||
| Paddy McGovern | F | 2nd Team |
| Kieran Enright | D | 3rd Team |
| Jake Figueiredo | D | 3rd Team |
| Devin Furphy | M | All-sportsmanship |
| NECC 2015 | ||
| Anthony Dominguez | D | 2nd Team |
| Nikolas Joseph | F | 2nd Team |
| Sean Deegan | D | All-sportsmanship |
| NECC 2014 | ||
| Erik Argueta | M | 1st Team |
| NECC 2013 | ||
| Pierre Massena | D | 1st Team |
| Erik Argueta | F | Honorable Mention |
| NECC 2012 | ||
| Pierre Massena | F | 1st Team |
| Connor Murray | M/F | 2nd Team |
| Erik Argueta | M/F | Honorable Mention |
| NECC 2011 | ||
| Tim Penrod | HC | Coach of the Year |
| Erik Argueta | M | Rookie of the Year |
| Nick Haggerty | F | 1st Team |
| Chris Hansen | D | 1st Team |
| Pierre Massena | F | 1st Team |
| Erik Argueta | M | 2nd Team |
| NECC 2010 | ||
| Nick Haggerty | F | Player of the Year |
| Nick Haggerty | F | 1st Team |
| Aaron Eschler | GK | 2nd Team |
| Chris Hansen | D | 2nd Team |
| Noah Massucci | D | Honorable Mention |
| NECC 2009 | ||
| Adrian Alexis | F | Rookie of the Year |
| Adrian Alexis | F | 1st Team |
| Nick Haggerty | F | 1st Team |
| Aaron Eschler | GK | 2nd Team |
| Tony Martinez | M | Honorable Mention |
| NECC 2008 | ||
| Aaron Eschler | GK | Goalkeeper of the Year |
| Aaron Eschler | GK | 1st Team |
| Nick Haggerty | F | 2nd Team |
| Tony Martinez | M | 2nd Team |
| Team Sportsmanship Award | ||
| NAIA 2006 | ||
| Israel Nery | GK | 2nd Team |
| GNAC 2003 | ||
| Matt Dubois | M | 1st Team |
| GNAC 2002 | ||
| Matt Dubois | M | 2nd Team |
| GNAC 2000 | ||
| Dan Dubois | F | 2nd Team |
| GNAC 1999 | ||
| Dan Dubois | F | 2nd Team |
| CSC 1993 | ||
| Tony Kasulinous | F | MVP |
| Tony Kasulinous | F | 1st Team |
| Jason Kennedy | M | 1st Team |
| Steve Monaghan | M | 2nd Team |
| Nate England | M | 2nd Team |
| Mark Tibbetts | M | 2nd Team |
| Andrew Dionne | D | Honorable Mention |
| Brett Leonas | M | Honorable Mention |
| Andrew Dionne | Scholar-Athlete | |
| CSC 1991 | ||
| Derek Lawson | F | MVP |
| Derek Lawson | F | 1st Team |
| John Joe Monaghan | F | 1st Team |
| Tony Kasulinos | F | 1st Team |
| Ken LaBonte | M | 2nd Team |
| Scott Moulton | M | 2nd Team |